← search

Xerjoff mefisto dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus

The most agreed-upon dupe for Xerjoff mefisto is Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage, named by 4 distinct people across 3 threads.

alternatives
2
in graph
2
voices
14

not in the graph yet

open in universe →
01

Ranked alternatives

#FragranceBucketEvidenceConsensusBuy
01Club de Nuit Sillage

Armaf

“It is inspired by Creed SMW and xerjoff Mefisto.”what reddit says ↓

  • Most accurate
  • Best spinoff
4 voices · 3 threadssimilar vibe100
02Citrus Water

Montagne

“Citrus Water (Montagne mefisto clone) smells 1:1 and is such an amazing scent to experience”what reddit says ↓

  • Best value
2 voices · 2 threadsidentical67no offers
02

What Reddit says

A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.

Club de Nuit SillageArmaf

4 voices · 3 threads

40% call it identical or very closeNo recorded disagreement
  • Several users consider Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage to be quite similar in scent to Xerjoff Mefisto.
  • Some note that while Sillage gets close to the overall vibe, it is not quite as good as Mefisto.

  • “It is inspired by Creed SMW and xerjoff Mefisto.”

    reddit post ↗

  • “i tried sillage and it’s okay but not as good as mefisto”

    reddit ↗

  • “if it’s similar to Mefisto I think CDN Sillage get’s pretty close to it”

    reddit ↗

  • “I have seen in Fragrantica that Club de Nuit Sillage of Armaf is very similar to it”

    reddit post ↗

Citrus WaterMontagne

2 voices · 2 threads

53% call it identical or very closeNo recorded disagreement — though only 2 voices were counted
  • Reddit users recognize Montagne Citrus Water as an inspired clone of Xerjoff Mefisto.
  • Community feedback is highly positive, with comments describing the scent profile as a 1:1 match to the original.
  • There is limited discussion available, with no notable disagreements or details regarding longevity mentioned.

  • “Citrus Water (Montagne mefisto clone) smells 1:1 and is such an amazing scent to experience”

    reddit ↗

  • “Citrus Water (inspired by Xerjoff Mefisto)”

    reddit ↗
03

Also a dupe of

The originals people say this bottle imitates, counted the same way as everything else here: each line is the number of separate people who made that claim in a real Reddit thread.

#OriginalEvidenceAlso ranked
01Silver Mountain Water

Creed

“Xerjoff Mefisto is the best clone of SMW.”

8 voices · 7 threadssimilar vibe—