Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage is Armaf Derby Club House Blanche, named by 5 distinct people across 4 threads.
- alternatives
- 2
- in graph
- 9
- voices
- 491
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Derby Club House Blanche Armaf “It’s like CDN Sillage (Creed Silver Mountain Water DNA) but they pulled back a little. It’s not so overwhelming but last a long, long time. It’s more delicate but not in projection. It’s softer with more floral scent but still crisp. To me it smells like they repurposed Sillage with a small variation”what reddit says ↓ |
| 5 voices · 4 threadsidentical | 100 | |
| 02 | Supremacy in Heaven Afnan “supremacy in heaven is just a all around better fragrance. It has the same dry down with a way nicer opening”what reddit says ↓ |
| 8 voices · 6 threadssimilar vibe | 57 |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Derby Club House BlancheArmaf
5 voices · 4 threads
- Reddit users overwhelmingly agree that Derby Club House Blanche is functionally identical to Club de Nuit Sillage, with several describing it as the exact same juice.
- Some note subtle differences, describing Blanche as slightly softer, more floral, less metallic, or even stronger than Sillage.
- Reviewers report excellent longevity and consider Blanche a better value since Sillage carries a price markup due to the popular line name.
“It’s like CDN Sillage (Creed Silver Mountain Water DNA) but they pulled back a little. It’s not so overwhelming but last a long, long time. It’s more delicate but not in projection. It’s softer with more floral scent but still crisp. To me”
reddit post ↗“I have a 5ml decant of Sillage and an older bottle of Armaf Derby Club House Blanche and for my money there is little to no difference between that and the much hyped Sillage.”
reddit ↗“Armaf Derby Club House Blanche is better than Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage. It is the exact same juice, but stronger.”
reddit ↗“armaf derby club house blanche is the same juice in a different bottle. CDN is just marked up because it's a more popular line but I can confirm that they are the same.”
reddit ↗“also, derby clubhouse Blanche is pretty good too and less metallic than sillage 👍”
reddit ↗
Supremacy in HeavenAfnan
8 voices · 6 threads
- Most users view Supremacy in Heaven as a smoother, better-blended alternative to CDN Sillage with a similar dry down, though a few feel they do not smell alike.
- Fans often prefer Supremacy in Heaven's opening over Sillage's sharp citrus blast, rating the overall scent profile up to 90% the same.
- Users note a trade-off in performance, describing Supremacy in Heaven as dialed down compared to Sillage with less projection and longevity.
Where people agree
“supremacy in heaven is just a all around better fragrance. It has the same dry down with a way nicer opening”
reddit ↗“I want to try SiH I’ve heard it’s CDN Sillage but better.”
reddit ↗“SiH is probably the best alternative to CDN Sillage. I cannot stand Sillage”
reddit ↗“Take Sillage and dial it down by about 50%. SiH is better blended and smoother in the opening in my opinion but it's a trade off when it comes to longevity and projection.”
reddit ↗“Sillage, Eau De Montagne, and In Heaven smell like 90% the same”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
Also a dupe of
The originals people say this bottle imitates, counted the same way as everything else here: each line is the number of separate people who made that claim in a real Reddit thread.
| # | Original | Evidence | Also ranked |
|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Silver Mountain Water Creed “Club de nuit Sillage (Silver Mountain Water)” | 443 voices · 410 threadsvery close | Best value |
| 02 | mefisto Xerjoff “It is inspired by Creed SMW and xerjoff Mefisto.” | 4 voices · 3 threadssimilar vibe | Best spinoff |
| 03 | Club de Nuit Intense Man Armaf “They do not smell similar.” | 4 voices · 3 threadsdifferent | — |
| 04 | Chrome Azzaro “For the first few minutes it’s chrome to a T!! During the dry down it still maintains the chrome similarities but gets a little more zing to it.” | 3 voices · 2 threadssimilar vibe | — |
| 05 | Cool Water Davidoff “Can’t talk about SMW but this is a better more refined Coolwater. I bought it for under £30.00 and at that it’s well worth it.” | 3 voices · 1 threaddifferent | — |
| 06 | Virgin Island Water Creed “smells identical if not slightly better but with beast mode longevity.” | 2 voices · 1 threadidentical | Best value |
| 07 | Millesime Imperial Creed “video about milliseme imperial and sillage. I already had Creed so I bought a bottle to see how i liked it and really enjoyed it. It is linear but it's still good. From there I bought a few more but typically compared them to the og. If the scent profile was close I know I have a winner.” | 2 voices · 2 threadsvery close | — |