Creed Silver Mountain Water dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Creed Silver Mountain Water is Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage, named by 443 distinct people across 410 threads.
- alternatives
- 2
- in graph
- 42
- voices
- 982
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Club de Nuit Sillage Armaf “Club de nuit Sillage (Silver Mountain Water)”what reddit says ↓ |
| 443 voices · 410 threadsvery close | 100 | |
| 02 | Supremacy in Heaven Afnan “Supremacy in heaven- citrus forward with a very light tone of fruits in the background and a nice green tea smell and it dries down to a nice wood base. Dupes creed silver mountain water (favorite at the moment)”what reddit says ↓ |
| 131 voices · 128 threadssimilar vibe | 19 |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Club de Nuit SillageArmaf
443 voices · 410 threads
- Most users consider it very close to Silver Mountain Water, especially in the air, with an added punch of citrus.
- Some dissenters find it excessively sharp and lacking the calming green tea notes of the original.
- Reviewers note that it excels in high heat, even outperforming the original Creed fragrance in warm weather.
Where people agree
“Club de nuit Sillage (Silver Mountain Water)”
reddit post ↗“This is in fact VERY close to the OG! There is a bit more of a citrusy punch in the opening especially when smelled up close, but in the air even in the opening it’s so damn close to SMW that to the untrained nose you probably would not be”
reddit post ↗“Armaf CDN sillage: if you live in high heats environment this one shines like no other in high heat it literally smells like a punch of cold almost icy water in the high heats I actually have creeds SMW and it doesn't perform as well as thi”
reddit post ↗“In my opinion this is one of the best clones I’ve ever had/ever come across. It’s identical to SMW, literally 1:1, projects like a train, lasts like 8-9 hours.”
reddit post ↗
Where people disagree
“I love silver mountain water but this is not it. It is way too strong, pungently sharp and has not got any of that greeness/ tea. SMW is supposed to be a calming feel good scent but this just smells not that close and not that good. 5/10”
reddit post ↗“I have to say, it doesn't resemble SMW at all. It lacks that cool, inky note I loved in the original.”
reddit post ↗“CDN Sillage blasts you with that intense metallic citrus, but for that it sacrifices the smoothness and other notes SWM has”
reddit post ↗“I really like it, but I tried Silver Mountain Water from an online decant store and found it nothing like it.”
reddit ↗“this is supposed to be a dupe of Creed Mountain Water but is quite nice to my nose as a warm weather unisex. I don’t think it smells like SMW though- runs around $30 Armaf Club De Nuit Sillage”
reddit ↗
Supremacy in HeavenAfnan
131 voices · 128 threads
- Reddit users generally consider it a close, easier-to-wear dupe with a similar clean citrus and green tea vibe to Silver Mountain Water.
- Reviewers note the opening leans more citrus-forward—sometimes likened to D&G Light Blue—before becoming up to 95% similar in the drydown.
- Some describe it as a stronger-performing alternative that benefits from maceration to bring the scent closer to the original.
Where people agree
“Supremacy in heaven- citrus forward with a very light tone of fruits in the background and a nice green tea smell and it dries down to a nice wood base. Dupes creed silver mountain water (favorite at the moment)”
reddit post ↗“whoever made supremacy … GOD SENT ! this is basically a stronger version with a little twist compared to creed imo”
reddit post ↗“the dry down is almost like 95% similar to smw”
reddit post ↗“Supremacy in heaven....y'all already know ... My girl was like hold on...idk if u can wear that out without me(creed silver mountain water)”
reddit post ↗“Supremacy in Heaven really embodies that fresh office scent. It's a dupe of Silver Mountain Water by Creed and while I haven't smelled the OG yet, I know Afnan does have a tendency of mimicking fragrances really well.”
reddit post ↗
Where people disagree
“Afnan Supremacy in Heaven (Silver Mountain Water style)”
reddit post ↗“I wanted sth that smells like Crees SWM and this most certainly doesn’t”
reddit post ↗“I just got SIH. Never smelled SMW but SIH smells like a niche baby wipe.”
reddit ↗“Afnan Supremacy In Heaven (Creed SMW) - Compared to the original, this one is more harsh and has a lot more woods. Bought it after smelling SMW, but it didn't live up to the OG. Should've gone with CDN Sillage. 6/10”
reddit post ↗“Supremacy is nowhere near a 1:1. It’s a twist for sure, I have a legit bottle of SMW and Supremacy is maybe 65%. Smells good, but it’s not SMW and definitely its own thing.”
reddit ↗