Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille is Al Haramain Amber Oud Tobacco Edition, named by 283 distinct people across 253 threads.
- alternatives
- 2
- in graph
- 66
- voices
- 1182
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Amber Oud Tobacco Edition Al Haramain “The best dupe of tv I've ever tried is Al haramain amber oud Tobacco edition, it's so good id never consider buying the original.”what reddit says ↓ |
| 283 voices · 253 threadsvery close | 100 | |
| 02 | Charuto Tobacco Vanille EDP Paris Corner “Charuto Tobacco Vanille by Paris Corner is an impressive clone of TF Tobacco Vanille.”what reddit says ↓ |
| 102 voices · 105 threadssimilar vibe | 31 | no offers |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Amber Oud Tobacco EditionAl Haramain
283 voices · 253 threads
- Reddit considers this one of the best Tobacco Vanille dupes available, with many calling it extremely close or nearly identical.
- Users note it is roughly 90–95% similar, with a slightly sharper opening and noticeably less vanilla than the original.
- Some reviewers find the scent so good that they would not consider purchasing the Tom Ford original.
Where people agree
“6. TF Tobacco Vanille - Al Haramain”
reddit post ↗“This is extremely close to TF Tobacco Vanille. Not a perfect 1:1, but I’d honestly say 90–95% similar. The main difference is the opening. Amber Oud TE opens a bit different and slightly sharper compared to TF TV’s smoother, richer opening.”
reddit post ↗“The best dupe of tv I've ever tried is Al haramain amber oud Tobacco edition, it's so good id never consider buying the original.”
reddit ↗“Al Haramain Amber Oud Tobacco. I have both and they smell identical.”
reddit ↗“I tried them all and Al haramain oud tobacco is by far the best.”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“Al haramain is a great fragrance, dont get me wrong. Very strong performace, lasts into the next day. But i just don't get much tobacco from it. I get more of a masculine sweet cinnamon.”
reddit ↗“The AL Haramain is very cinnamon and I don't get much Tobacco from it. But al haramain has amazing performance.”
reddit ↗“Amber Oud smells very strong synthetic toffee. Cannot make out the Tobacco nor the Vanilla. I have sampled the Tom Ford OG on my skin a couple of times at the Mall so, I'm fairly aware of how it smells. This doesn't seem to be even near com”
reddit post ↗“This is pretty different from tobacco vanille. It’s literally just like an Indian milky street chai For the first half of its life on your person. Then it dries down into a spicier tobacco vanille for an hour or two.”
reddit ↗“I also bought Al Haramain Amber Oud Tobacco, and it smells quite different from Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille, definitely heavier on the amber side.”
reddit ↗
Charuto Tobacco Vanille EDPParis Corner
102 voices · 105 threads
- Reviewers generally consider it an impressive clone that captures a similar vibe to Tom Ford, highlighting a very close dry down.
- Compared to the original, users note it leans slightly sweeter and more vanilla-dominant, though some feel it is not quite as well-blended.
- At roughly twenty-five dollars, the fragrance is widely praised for offering great value at a fraction of the designer price.
Where people agree
“Charuto Tabacco Vanille: got this one today. It definitely smells like tabacco with a lot of sweet notes, almost kind of fruity. Vanilla is also pretty dominant. Definitely comes closer to TF but also not exactly the same. Really good fragr”
reddit post ↗“Charuto Tobacco Vanille by Paris Corner is an impressive clone of TF Tobacco Vanille.”
reddit post ↗“Charuto tobacco vanille: great scent once in dry down, very close to the original at 1/10 of the original price”
reddit post ↗“Paris corner charuto tobacco vanille. Both are good, al haramain is well blended, charuto is a bit more vanilla”
reddit ↗“Charuto Tobacco Vanille - TF tobacco vanille”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“I have tried Charuto Tobacco Vanille but it wasn't good as I thought. I'm going to try one of these for this winter. Which one is the closest to Tom Ford?”
reddit post ↗“Charuto was pure honey sweetness. Like honey, no tobacco, no vanilla, just honey. It was so bad my wife started calling me Pooh Bear when I'd wear it. I couldn't give the stuff away.”
reddit ↗“While not reminding me of the tom ford TV it was not disagreeable.”
reddit post ↗“charuto tobaco vanille - reminds me of a chinese preserved bayberry with a hint of anise.”
reddit ↗“I have a decant of Tobacco Vanille and a bottle of Charuto... I'm not a fan of either. TF is the better of the 2 with more sweeter notes, Charuto has the tobacco notes, but I don't find it has the prominent sweet note that the TF has.”
reddit ↗