Parfums de Marly Greenley dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Parfums de Marly Greenley is French Avenue Aether, the highest-ranked alternative by community consensus.
- alternatives
- 2
- in graph
- —
- voices
- —
laying out…
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Aether French Avenue |
| 168 voices · 147 threads | 100 | |
| 02 | Sherif Lattafa |
| 24 voices · 26 threads | 7 |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
AetherFrench Avenue
168 voices · 147 threads
- Most users find French Avenue Aether to be very close or nearly indistinguishable from Greenley, offering great value at under $40.
- Reviewers note that while the scent profile captures Greenley's fresh DNA, it misses some of the original's depth during the drydown.
- Performance opinions are mixed, with some praising its longevity while a dissenting user claims it fades quickly into a cheap-smelling base.
Where people agree
“French Avenue’s Aether: PDM Greenley clone that is under $40!”
reddit post ↗“the one in the shop was pretty much indistinguishable from Greenly.”
reddit post ↗“Aether by French Avenue in my opinion gets the closest in profile and performs the best out of the others I have. Opens very close to Greenley, but misses the depth of the other notes as it transitions into the dry down.”
reddit post ↗“Aether to me is about 90% of Greenley, pretty much indistinguishable.”
reddit post ↗“Aether a dupe of PDM Greenley, smells absolutely incredible and is very close to the real deal.”
reddit post ↗
Where people disagree
“AETHER - NO! SAVE YOUR MONEY! It smells just like greenly in the opening but lasts all of one min. The dry down smells cheap AF, like a dollar store men’s lotion.”
reddit post ↗“I have tried greenly and aether was way off the mark”
reddit ↗“I just did a full four days of wear for Greenly OG decant and clones (Midori, Aether decant, and Green Envy) - None of those shits lasted longer than 2hrs for projection.”
reddit ↗“Aether is a terrible performer for me and the smell isn't worth the effort to acquire IMO”
reddit ↗“It’s about on par with the original projection-wise. With less longevity. So I guess technically yeah, that would make the performance bad🤣”
reddit ↗
SherifLattafa
24 voices · 26 threads
- Reddit views Lattafa Sherif as a similar fresh, green alternative to Greenley rather than an exact 1:1 clone.
- Some note it leans sweeter with more prominent apple notes, though impressions of the drydown are mixed.
- Users consider it a strong value around $25–$30, with one reviewer reporting good longevity of 6 to 8 hours.
Where people agree
“Greenly → Sherif – Lattafa Perfumes”
reddit post ↗“Lataffa Sherif 9/10 💚 Apple/Green masculine scent. Irish Spring/Greenly clone. Lasts 6-8 hours, feeling clean the whole way. Cannot wait for spring/summer. Got it for 30. Banger for sure.”
reddit post ↗“Unfortunately, Greenley doesn't last that much; it has a bit of a grassy feeling and a woody/musky drydown, which is not necessarily mass-appealing. I wanted something with less wood and more apple, and Sherif hit the spot for my daily summ”
reddit post ↗
Where people disagree
“Sherif by Lattafa. When I first got this I really disliked it. It was very vegetal green and not smooth at all. After a few months the vegetal part has gone away and this is the sweetest version out of all the dupes. The opening is decent,”
reddit post ↗“I'm a big advocate for clones, but Greenly is way better than Sherif, imo”
reddit ↗“I don't tink lattafa Sherif is the only greenly dupe. There is a French avenue one too. I forget the name.. my issue with Sherif is that it does not last at all!”
reddit ↗