Mugler a*men pure malt dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Mugler a*men pure malt is Fragrance World Fragrance Star Men Nebula, named by 69 distinct people across 72 threads.
- alternatives
- 3
- in graph
- 8
- voices
- 105
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Fragrance Star Men Nebula Fragrance World “33. Star Men Nebula (Pure Malt) 7.5/10 great clone decent longevity”what reddit says ↓ |
| 69 voices · 72 threadssimilar vibe | 100 | |
| 02 | Fragrance Posh Malt Fragrance World “It is a dupe of AMen pure malt”what reddit says ↓ |
| 14 voices · 14 threadssimilar vibe | 22 | no offers |
| 03 | Galactic Men Elixir Maison Alhambra “Maison Alhambra Galactic Men Elixir - this one is slept on but it's such a solid fucking dupe of Pure Malt. Just sexy.”what reddit says ↓ |
| 5 voices · 5 threadsvery close | 7 |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Fragrance Star Men NebulaFragrance World
69 voices · 72 threads
- Reddit users generally consider Star Men Nebula a great clone of Pure Malt that captures its signature malt whiskey, patchouli, and vanilla profile.
- Estimates on closeness vary from roughly 75% to nearly identical unless compared side by side, with some reviewers actually preferring the clone.
- The fragrance is widely viewed as an affordable no-brainer offering average to decent longevity.
Where people agree
“33. Star Men Nebula (Pure Malt) 7.5/10 great clone decent longevity”
reddit post ↗“Star Men Nebula (Pure Malt) 7.5/10 great clone decent longevity”
reddit post ↗“They're only about 75% close, but I actually PREFER Nebula!”
reddit post ↗“get star nebula too really close to pur malt , unless you compare side by side its a perfect closen and smelles even a bit better sub $20is a no brainer”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“Mine smells ultra sour like an old-school fougere; nothing like the Mugler fragrance in any way.”
reddit ↗“Pure malt was $30 frag some time ago, so prob wasn't the best quality either, but I've heard that Nebula is a bit lower quality”
reddit ↗“Star Man Nebula when I first smelled it, I thought the same, but I let it sit for a little and now I wear it from time to time, but honestly it isn’t the best quality, and doesn’t last, and I hear fragrance world actually has ANOTHER Pure M”
reddit ↗
Fragrance Posh MaltFragrance World
14 voices · 14 threads
- Reddit users consider Posh Malt an impressive clone, rating it between 90% and 98% close to Pure Malt.
- Reviewers note it may smell slightly fruitier or more airy than the original, with some likening it to pre-reformulation batches.
- The fragrance is praised for its strong longevity and excellent value at around 25 euros.
“Fragrance World Posh Malt is about 98% Pure Malt to me, with the 2% making it more airy and somehow longer lasting.”
reddit ↗“Very satisfied with this clone, maybe 90% close to original, its little more fruity smelly but I like it, just like before reformulated Pure malt. , Its a steal for 25 euro!”
reddit post ↗“It is a dupe of AMen pure malt”
reddit post ↗“I have Posh Malt and love it. Longevity is good and it smells fantastic. Id love to hear from anyone that's smelled both to compare”
reddit ↗“best pure malt clone? i have posh malt and star man nebula which smell almost identical”
reddit post ↗
Galactic Men ElixirMaison Alhambra
5 voices · 5 threads
Where people agree
“Men Elixir is Pure Malt”
reddit ↗“They are supposed to be clones of Mugler Pure Malt and Pure Havana”
reddit post ↗“Maison Alhambra Galactic Men Elixir - this one is slept on but it's such a solid fucking dupe of Pure Malt. Just sexy.”
reddit ↗“There is another one called Galactic Men Elixir , with similar presentation. That´s the one that clones Pure Malt.”
reddit ↗“Just bought Maison Alhambra Galactic Men Elixir, another Pure Malt clone”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“Not close to Prada and worse Pure Malt clone...”
reddit ↗