Montale Arabians Tonka dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Montale Arabians Tonka is Riiffs Momento, the highest-ranked alternative by community consensus.
- alternatives
- 3
- in graph
- —
- voices
- —
laying out…
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Momento Riiffs |
| 63 voices · 43 threads | 100 | no offers |
| 02 | Karus Secret Musk Khadlaj |
| 33 voices · 34 threads | 65 | no offers |
| 03 | Amber Oud Dubai Night Al Haramain |
| 44 voices · 44 threads | 37 |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
MomentoRiiffs
63 voices · 43 threads
Where people agree
“Memento RiiFFS is the closest. It scratches the same itches and cravings as Arabians Tonka that i have been looking for. It is dense, cloying, dark, thick, and warm. It has the same sugary dark sweetness that Arabians Tonka has.”
reddit post ↗“I have never smelled Montale Arabians Tonka, which Memento is supposedly cloning, so I cannot give you a similarity percentage.”
reddit post ↗“Riffs Momento! It’s the clone or in the DNA of móntale Arabians tonka!”
reddit post ↗“I’ve smelled Montale Arabians Tonka before, but I personally can’t justify paying 3–5x the price of this for a similar scent profile. Swipe to see the second picture. No matter how good Arabians Tonka is, I just cant justify paying that muc”
reddit post ↗“This is widely known as a dupe of Arabians Tonka and honestly, I get the hype.”
reddit post ↗
Where people disagree
“Smells Like Arabian Tonka Ect However Upon Spraying Getting Quite A Alcohol Smell With Some Oud Lasts No More Than 30 Mins (Being Generous) Theres No Beast Mode About It Very Mid/Average Scent I Have Arabian Tonka Which Smells Great Alot Mo”
reddit post ↗“I have compared OG and momento side by side and to me the rose note is different. I can smell layers in OG but Momento is more simplistic and linear nose.”
reddit ↗
Karus Secret MuskKhadlaj
33 voices · 34 threads
- Reddit users consistently identify Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk as a direct clone of Montale Arabians Tonka, with several describing it as an almost spot-on or 1-to-1 match.
- Commenters frequently praise the fragrance for having niche-level quality and standout strength compared to competing clones.
- The community shows clear consensus around its accuracy, with no notable disagreements reported.
Where people agree
“Karus Secret musk (Montale Arabia Tonka)”
reddit post ↗“Karus secret musk khadlaj is arabian tonka”
reddit ↗“Karus Secret Musk by Khadlaj is THE SAME as Arabians Tonka. Secret Musk is actually less harsh imo.”
reddit post ↗“Karus secret musk - khadlaj. Niche quality juice , clone of Montale Arabians tonka”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“Ever since getting disappointed by karus secret musk which is supposed to be beastly arabians tonka clone, and oud noir (ombre nomade), i am never trusting them ever again.”
reddit ↗“You go noseblind very easily with Karus secret musk, and there's no prominent sugar note in it, I'd say the original is way more worth it.”
reddit ↗“Not worth it. This has a lot of BR540 mixed with Arabians Tonka (Tonka + Oud)”
reddit ↗“it's a completely different fragrance! It smells like I poured a beer in my neck and a bit like leather, completely different, I can't even get close to a sweet smell like Arabian tonka. Blind bought this due to this thread but is one of th”
reddit ↗
Amber Oud Dubai NightAl Haramain
44 voices · 44 threads
- Reddit consensus generally views Amber Oud Dubai Night as having a similar vibe or being a twist on Arabians Tonka rather than an exact clone.
- Opinions on closeness are divided, with some calling it a very good match while others estimate it is under fifty percent similar.
- Users note that Dubai Night introduces an added freshness on top, making the oud and rose profile more versatile for year-round wear.
Where people agree
“Dubai Night - Arabian Tonka”
reddit post ↗“Amber Oud Dubai Nights by Al Haramain – Clone of Arabians Tonka by Montale. Just smells classy — rich, deep, and smooth. Plus the packaging is insanely high quality. Feels like a $300 bottle.”
reddit ↗“Btw if you like Arabian’s Tonka, please get Dubai Night it’s a fvckn banger and can be worn all year round cause of the added freshness on top”
reddit post ↗“It is similar to Arabians Tonka but not a dupe of it in my opinion.”
reddit post ↗“Dubai Night quickly became my favorite. It has a scent similar to Arabian’s Tonka, which I’ve tried before, and it’s a perfect match.”
reddit post ↗
Where people disagree
“people say it's not even close to the Arabians Tonka”
reddit post ↗“I have Dubai Night and currently, it's not very close to AT.”
reddit ↗“It doesn't remind me much of Arabians Tonka, because I feel like this is a lot more mass appealing and toned down”
reddit ↗“Crazy thing is I smelled Arabian Tonka a couple weeks ago and yea, this is definitely a clone of it, no doubt about it.”
reddit ↗“It does have arabian tonka thing going on in the background but then they added this lemon or apple at the top which is harsh to my nose.”
reddit ↗
Also a dupe of
The originals people say this bottle imitates, counted the same way as everything else here: each line is the number of separate people who made that claim in a real Reddit thread.
| # | Original | Evidence | Also ranked |
|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Baccarat Rouge 540 Maison Francis Kurkdjian “Get arabian tonka, its even better imo but same dna. Yes its still expensive around 90 bucks but worth it” | 4 voices · 4 threadssimilar vibe | — |