Melanie Martinez Cry Baby Perfume Milk dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Melanie Martinez Cry Baby Perfume Milk is Oakcha Praise The Perfume, the highest-ranked alternative by community consensus.
- alternatives
- 2
- in graph
- —
- voices
- —
laying out…
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Praise The Perfume Oakcha |
| 42 voices · 35 threads | 100 | no offers |
| 02 | Andromeda's Cry Baby Andromeda's Moon |
| 8 voices · 9 threads | 50 | no offers |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Praise The PerfumeOakcha
42 voices · 35 threads
- Reddit users frequently recommend Oakcha Praise The Perfume as a delicious, sweet, and lactonic alternative to Cry Baby Perfume Milk.
- While many prefer it over competing dupes, some note it captures a similar vibe rather than serving as an exact 1:1 replacement.
Where people agree
“I had the Oakcha version (my bestie loved it so I gave it to her), and it was delicious.”
reddit ↗“I liked Oakcha’s way more”
reddit ↗“Praise the Perfume (Crybaby dupe)”
reddit ↗“Oakcha Praise the Perfume (Crybaby dupe) is my signature scent and they’re super budget friendly.”
reddit ↗“Praise the Perfume (dupe of Melanie Martinez Cry Baby)”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“CryBaby Dupes - I tried Miim Miic and Oakcha, I liked Oakchas more but I just have to accept the fact nothing will smell like the original to my nose. So I rather not have the dupes.”
reddit post ↗“Oakcha has one. But it’s oakcha so”
reddit ↗“Praise the Perfume is very heavy on the woody notes. It’s much more unisex than Crybaby, almost like a cologne version, but maybe only 20% similar. With that being said, I much prefer the Oakcha in terms of quality and notes.”
reddit ↗“I have PTP and a teeny decant of the OG. They don’t smell similar really but PTP is really nice!”
reddit ↗“Praise the Perfume - ok so, this one smells SUPER SYMTHETIC initially. It’s super sweet and fruity and smells nothing like Melanie Martinez crybaby milk.”
reddit ↗
Andromeda's Cry BabyAndromeda's Moon
8 voices · 9 threads
- Multiple reviewers consider this the closest dupe available, noting it smells identical to the original perfume even when compared side-by-side.
- While widely praised, at least one user preferred alternative dupes over Andromeda's Moon.
- International buyers note that high shipping costs and purchasing difficulties can significantly drive up the price.
Where people agree
“The closest dupe ive found is Andromeda’s Moon version. It smells literally like when I first got the Crybaby perfume back when it was released.”
reddit ↗“I got one I really liked from andromeda moon. I actually never smelled the original but someone mentioned it smelled closest to the real deal.”
reddit ↗“There’s a few dupes I do truly love, like Andromeda Moon’s Cry Baby dupe”
reddit ↗“Andromedas version of the closest imo. It smells exactly like crybaby from when i first got it at a melanie concert lol.”
reddit ↗“The closest dupe is andromedas version.”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“both the one from andromedas moon and monn perfumes have a note that makes them smell exactly like pine air freshener mixed with the purple fabuloso”
reddit ↗