← search

Lorenzo Pazzaglia Van Py Rhum dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus

The most agreed-upon dupe for Lorenzo Pazzaglia Van Py Rhum is French Avenue X Xandal, named by 7 distinct people across 4 threads.

alternatives
1
in graph
1
voices
7
2 nodes · 1 edgesopen in universe →
01

Ranked alternatives

#FragranceBucketEvidenceConsensusBuy
01X Xandal

French Avenue

“If you’re into Van Phy Rum or Van Extasy from Lorenzo, this is in the same lane. Really nice surprise, and honestly? Worth it.”what reddit says ↓

  • Most accurate
  • Best value
7 voices · 4 threadsvery close100
02

What Reddit says

A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.

X XandalFrench Avenue

7 voices · 4 threads

83% call it identical or very closeNo recorded disagreement
  • Reddit consensus rates X Xandal as very close to Van Py Rhum, with multiple users estimating around a 95% similarity in scent profile.
  • Users note that Van Py Rhum is darker and more subtle, while X Xandal is sharper, louder, and projects more.
  • Both fragrances easily last all day, making X Xandal widely praised as an excellent budget-friendly alternative.
  • “If you’re into Van Phy Rum or Van Extasy from Lorenzo, this is in the same lane. Really nice surprise, and honestly? Worth it.”

    reddit post ↗
  • “In short, yes, they are VERY similar. Van Py Rhum is a bit darker, and I'd say has more of something that makes me go a bit noseblind, like ambroxan or iso e super or whatever. In this rare case, I think X Xandal is better - stronger, more”

    reddit ↗
  • “Yes it is. I have a bottle of X Xandal and it's really good as well as unique. I have nothing quite like it in my collection. I would love to get to know how it compares to the OG, because according to some online reviews, it's difficult to”

    reddit ↗
  • “%95 same Van py rhum more rounded more suttle”

    reddit ↗
  • “Van Py Rhum has no sharp edges. It's very quiet and close to the skin. Xandal is louder and sharper. Van Py Rhum lasts forever. They're both very similar. I prefer Xandal, which is louder.”

    reddit ↗