Kayali Vanilla 28 dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus

• Reddit users consistently describe Fragrance World Elysia Vanilla as a spot-on match for Kayali Vanilla 28.
• Community members who own both fragrances strongly endorse the dupe over the original.
• There are no reported disagreements regarding the scent's accuracy, though discussions do not mention longevity or value.

Where people agree

• “Elysia Vanilla is near a enough a spot on dupe to my nose”

  reddit ↗

• “elysia vanilla is cheap and smells the exact same and projects even better”

  reddit ↗

• “Elysia smells even better for a fraction of the price imo! I always get compliments when I wear it. Vanilla 28’s projection is kinda ass in comparison.”

  reddit ↗

• “Elysia Vanilla is the only dupe you need. It’s like 99.9%”

  reddit ↗

• “i have it and i d say it s superior to kayali. 9.5/10”

  reddit ↗

Where people disagree

• “This is not a dupe to me, not even a cousin, not even related.”

  reddit post ↗

• “tried both the Fragrance World and Paris Corner dupes of V28 and both were medicine bombs to my nose”

  reddit ↗

• Reviewers widely consider Eshal Vanilla a very close match to Vanilla 28, often describing it as a stronger and slightly spicier version.
• Users consistently report that the dupe boasts superior longevity and beast-mode projection compared to the original.
• The fragrance is frequently praised as an exceptional value, offering better overall performance at a fraction of Kayali's price.

Where people agree

• “Paris Corner’s Eshal Vanilla. Nearly identical smell, lasts HOURS longer, and you can’t beat the price!!!”

  reddit ↗

• “Eshal vanilla by Paris corner, is Vanilla 28 in BEAST mode! For 1/3 of the price!”

  reddit ↗

• “eshal vanilla by paris corner!! it’s even better and really really best mode”

  reddit ↗

• “Eshal Vanilla from Paris Corner is everything I wanted Vanilla 28 to be. The brown sugar note is stunning, the lasting power and projection is extremely impressive and it’s STRONG”

  reddit ↗

• “Eshal Vanilla (my bottle was manufactured in may) smells exactly like Vanilla 28 and is way cheaper”

  reddit ↗

Where people disagree

• “My 28 is black now, and it's so smooth and sweet, but eshal smells nothing like it”

  reddit ↗

• “They smell nothing alike though”

  reddit ↗

• “K28 smells smoother to my nose, maybe even more vanilla. Eschal smells more smokey, which I'm not positive that I like that aspect about it. Eschal is going to be more of a cooler months scent. So I'll revisit it later this year. As of righ”

  reddit ↗

• “Vanilla Seduction is even better than Vanilla 28 IMO”

  reddit ↗

• “Vanilla 28 specifically doesn’t last well on me………..but Vanilla Seduction is just it. It’s sexy, it’s long lasting, it layers well with everything and it’s cheap!”

  reddit ↗

• “Vanilla Seduction by MAISON ASRAR (Dupe for Vanilla 28)”

  reddit ↗

• “Vanilla Seduction by Maison Asrar.”

  reddit ↗

• “Seduction is apparently a vanilla 28 dupe.”

  reddit ↗