← search

Guerlain L'Homme Ideal dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus

The most agreed-upon dupe for Guerlain L'Homme Ideal is Fragrance World Fragrance Supreme L'Homme Eau de Parfum, the highest-ranked alternative by community consensus.

alternatives
2
in graph
—
voices
—

laying out…

01

Ranked alternatives

#FragranceBucketEvidenceConsensusBuy
01Fragrance Supreme L'Homme Eau de Parfum

Fragrance World

what reddit says ↓

  • Most accurate
  • Best spinoff
20 voices · 21 threads100
02Fragrance Supreme L'Homme Extreme

Fragrance World

what reddit says ↓

  • Best value
3 voices · 3 threads26
02

What Reddit says

A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.

Fragrance Supreme L'Homme Eau de ParfumFragrance World

20 voices · 21 threads

45% call it identical or very close
  • Reddit users generally consider this a strong clone with a very similar vibe to Guerlain L'Homme Ideal, with one reviewer rating it around 90% accurate.
  • There is slight confusion within the community over whether it clones the original Eau de Toilette or the Eau de Parfum concentration.
  • Wearers report positive feedback and good performance, noting that the fragrance lasts a long time on the skin and garners compliments.

Where people agree

  • “The second one is really good! My bottle is almost empty, and I will definitely buy a new one when it's finished. I've received quite a few compliments on this second clone—more than with the original. The scent lasts on you for quite a whi”

    reddit ↗

  • “2. Supreme l'homme(Guerlain edp)”

    reddit ↗

  • “Fragrance World has one for the EDP and Extreme flanker called Supreme L'homme and Supreme L'homme Extreme and they are damn good”

    reddit ↗

  • “surprised how close Supreme L'Homme and the OG smell very much alike. Great clone”

    reddit ↗

  • “For me, Supreme L'Homme is actually better than the OG. It's a little sweeter. The Cherry note stands out a little more and it's not as ashy.”

    reddit ↗

Where people disagree

  • “supreme L’homme for Guerlain but I like genericperfumes version of L’homme intense best. Supreme L’homme is weak.”

    reddit ↗

  • “I've tried Supreme L'Homme and Supreme L'Homme Extreme. They aren't half as good as the OG fragrances in my opinion.”

    reddit ↗

Fragrance Supreme L'Homme ExtremeFragrance World

3 voices · 3 threads

72% call it identical or very closeNo recorded disagreement — though only 3 voices were counted

  • “That’s Fragrance World cloning Guerlain”

    reddit ↗

  • “Supreme l'homme- Guerlain l'homme ideal(another beautiful clone)”

    reddit ↗

  • “Fragrance World Supreme L’homme Extreme”

    reddit ↗