Guerlain Herbes Troublantes dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Guerlain Herbes Troublantes is Montagne Herb Garden, named by 12 distinct people across 8 threads.
- alternatives
- 3
- in graph
- 4
- voices
- 43
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Herb Garden Montagne “Try Montagne Herb Garden. Montagnedecants.com if you don't want to pay the $40 for a bottle.”what reddit says ↓ |
| 12 voices · 8 threadssimilar vibe | 100 | no offers |
| 02 | Shiyaaka Sky Khadlaj “I reviewed shiyaaka Sky duping Herbes and it was very accurate but the profile wasnt for me”what reddit says ↓ |
| 22 voices · 16 threadssimilar vibe | 95 | no offers |
| 03 | Herbes Troublantes Montagne “It is extremely close to my untrained nose”what reddit says ↓ |
| 3 voices · 2 threadsvery close | 44 | no offers |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Herb GardenMontagne
12 voices · 8 threads
- Reddit users generally agree that Montagne Herb Garden captures a very similar vibe to Herbes Troublantes, with one reviewer rating it up to 98% close.
- Some note it is not fully accurate or as nuanced as the original, lacking the Guerlain's distinctive sparkle of freshness.
- At around $40 a bottle, it is frequently recommended as the primary dupe option for the fragrance.
Where people agree
“I have Herbes Troublantes, the Montagne dupe herb garden”
reddit ↗“Try Montagne Herb Garden. Montagnedecants.com if you don't want to pay the $40 for a bottle.”
reddit ↗“Montagne - Herb Garden (a Guerlain Herbes Troublantes clone. Smells like walking through a fresh, herby plant nursery after it's been watered by the rain, on a sparkly sunny day.)”
reddit ↗“I have herb garden and the OG, and they are pretty damn close. 98%, just missing the sparkle of freshness the OG has”
reddit ↗“I can confirm that it’s amazing and my buddy owns Herbes and thought I was wearing Herbes. He loved the Montagne version”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
Shiyaaka SkyKhadlaj
22 voices · 16 threads
- Reddit consensus views Khadlaj Shiyaaka Sky as sharing a similar vibe with Herbes Troublantes, though closeness estimates range from very accurate to around 50–60%.
- Reviewers note a sharp green opening that drifts closer in the drydown, with the original remaining fresher and lighter.
- Users offer mixed opinions on performance, with some reporting Shiyaaka Sky is stronger while others found the original had better longevity.
Where people agree
“I reviewed shiyaaka Sky duping Herbes and it was very accurate but the profile wasnt for me”
reddit post ↗“Shiyakka Sky (Herbes Troublantes Clone) Review After 5 wears”
reddit post ↗“Having smelled Herbes Troublantes in the Guerlain store I knew I had to find a dupe. Shiyaaka Sky - $31 (Tik Tok) Atralia Absolute Ice - $31 (Tik Tok)”
reddit post ↗“SKY vs ELEGANTO (Guerlain herbes troublantes clones)”
reddit post ↗“after 5 mins its about 90+ percent close, powdery green soapy with a bit of vetiver in the base its definitely got some white florals that make it unisex more unisex than imagination and more soapy clean with the neroli as well. if you dont”
reddit post ↗
Where people disagree
“It's alright compared to Herbes Troublantes, would probably say it is around 50-60% close. OG is much more fresh and light to wear than shiyaaka sky. Longevity - OG lasted longer than Shiyaaka”
reddit post ↗“He is doing this now to Guerlain Herbes Troubalantes, with Khadlaj Shiyaaka Sky”
reddit ↗“I must really not like the Herbes Troublantes dna because Sky does not smell good at all, it’s got like this weird almond smell, doesn’t smell clean or herby. Like to me it smells nothing like the notes say”
reddit ↗“It's almost the same but the dry down on the og is better and a lot smoother”
reddit ↗“OG is a lot smoother and light to wear, the dry down on shiyaaka gives me a small headache”
reddit ↗
Herbes TroublantesMontagne
3 voices · 2 threads
- Reddit users consider the Montagne dupe to be extremely close to the original fragrance.
- Community feedback is generally positive, with commenters describing it as a pleasant scent on its own that receives good reviews.
- Some commenters note that while it is well-regarded, they cannot personally verify the exact degree of accuracy to the original.