Creed Green Irish Tweed dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Creed Green Irish Tweed is Armaf Tres Nuit, named by 317 distinct people across 291 threads.
- alternatives
- 3
- in graph
- 50
- voices
- 1124
not in the graph yet
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Tres Nuit Armaf “Armaf Tres Nuit. 100% smells same as my Creed Green Irish Tweed. Stellar compliment getter. Pretty cheap too.”what reddit says ↓ |
| 317 voices · 291 threadssimilar vibe | 100 | |
| 02 | Amber Oud Carbon Edition Al Haramain “Same size bottles but major price difference ($50 vs $300). If I was blind folded and had to pick, I would say the Carbon was the OG and that the Green was the dupe. I prefer the fresher scent (reminds me of Irish Spring soap) of Carbon then the more woodsy scent of Irish Tweed. I love both but if I wanted to have 90 percent of the experience, I would stick with Carbon.”what reddit says ↓ |
| 68 voices · 79 threadssimilar vibe | 20 | |
| 03 | Green Irish Tweed Shobi “I’m comparing this Shobi version to my memory of the real GIT and to other clones I’ve tried like Egra, L’Aventure Knight, Amber Oud Carbon, and Cool Water. Shobi’s version is easily the greenest out of all of them, and I really enjoy it. Performance is unreal.”what reddit says ↓ |
| 10 voices · 16 threadsvery close | 3 | no offers |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Tres NuitArmaf
317 voices · 291 threads
- Armaf Tres Nuit is widely viewed as a reliable dupe that captures a similar vibe to Green Irish Tweed, often estimated around 85-90% similar.
- Reviewers note it is slightly sweeter and more floral than the original, with less fresh spice and balancing woodiness.
- Some users criticize it for having an unpleasant, synthetic or chemical undertone that prevents it from matching Creed's quality.
Where people agree
“Armaf Tres Nuit - Creed Green Irish Tweed”
reddit post ↗“2. Armaf Tres Nuit/ Creed Green Iris Tweed”
reddit post ↗“Armaf Tres Nuit. 100% smells same as my Creed Green Irish Tweed. Stellar compliment getter. Pretty cheap too.”
reddit ↗“picked up Tres Nuit and wow! I can certainly tell the difference but it’s so close and it last way longer than Creed. It’s almost 95% the same with slightly different opening and much better projection and performance. 10/10”
reddit ↗“I’ve never smelled green Irish tweed which is what this is inspired by… so I can’t compare to that. But I truly love this fragrance. It’s quickly becoming one of my favorites.”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“armaf tres nuit. has a synthetic wet dog smell even after a year of masturbation. Thought I just didnt like Creed GIT but the real stuff is just truly otherworldly and cant be replicated.”
reddit ↗“The Armaf Tres Nuit is it's own thing. I didn't find the fragrance to be BAD, but I felt that it had a sort of light chemical smell on the backend and the fragrance just smelled different to me.”
reddit post ↗“Tres Nuit is just trash quality and the worst performer out of the 3. It got this kind of printer paper after-scent, but has an overall balanced profile.”
reddit post ↗“tres nuit edp version (I don't think it smells like git though but it does smell great)”
reddit ↗“I have tres nuit edp , I feel like it doesn't smell very close to git it's nice but it's smells very different to my nose mainly lavender and Ambroxan”
reddit ↗
Amber Oud Carbon EditionAl Haramain
68 voices · 79 threads
- Reddit users generally describe Amber Oud Carbon Edition as a strong hybrid between Creed Green Irish Tweed and Davidoff Cool Water, capturing a fresher, soapier profile rather than an exact replica.
- Community members consider it an excellent, powerful performer that offers around 90 percent of the original's experience at a fraction of the price.
Where people agree
“If you're familiar with Coolwater and GIT, this is a hybrid of them both but way stronger and louder.”
reddit post ↗“Same size bottles but major price difference ($50 vs $300). If I was blind folded and had to pick, I would say the Carbon was the OG and that the Green was the dupe. I prefer the fresher scent (reminds me of Irish Spring soap) of Carbon the”
reddit post ↗“Spring: Amber Oud Carbon Edition (Creed GIT)”
reddit ↗“Highly recommend Amber Oud Carbon Edition. It lands somewhere in between GIT and Cool Water. More classy than CW but not as immaculate as GIT obviously. Performance is great.”
reddit ↗“check out “Al Haramain - Amber Oud (Carbon edition)” Imagine Cool Water and Green Irish Tweed had a kid… heavy blue, fresh opening… with a decent bit of green coming through during the dry-down. Beast projection and 8 hour performance”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“i actually did not like carbon at all. its ok i guess but it smelled almost exactly like fabric softener and not a "fragrance" it was maybe 50% similar to me. GIT has a much more green lemon verbina fresh natural smell and not a clean cloth”
reddit ↗“Amber Oud Carbon - far more aquatic/watery, closer to cool water and not as beast mode as YouTubers will have you believe”
reddit post ↗“Amber Oud Carbon has a nasty cumin/spice in the opening not present in GIT/Cool Water. Its dry down does have its merits, leans much more into the lemon side rather than the woods of the originals”
reddit ↗“I had carbon edition a long time ago and it smelled exactly like a dryer sheet. and not like GIT. its not a bad scent but its not GIT”
reddit ↗“Amber Oud Carbon is overpriced, and way more like a niche Cool Water than it is a GIT clone”
reddit ↗
Green Irish TweedShobi
10 voices · 16 threads
- Reddit users consider this dupe extremely close to Green Irish Tweed, describing it as even greener and slightly less bitter than the original.
- Reviewers consistently praise its powerful performance and longevity, often reporting that it projects stronger and lasts longer than the Creed version.
- A brief harsh opening is noted, and several users advise against adding extra essence because the standard formulation is already potent enough.
Where people agree
“I’m comparing this Shobi version to my memory of the real GIT and to other clones I’ve tried like Egra, L’Aventure Knight, Amber Oud Carbon, and Cool Water. Shobi’s version is easily the greenest out of all of them, and I really enjoy it. P”
reddit post ↗“Creed Green Irish Tweed | Score: 9/10 This one was a huge surprise to me. I got the chance to try the real thing in person a few weeks ago and they are extremely close from my memory. The opening is a little harsh and smells a little like s”
reddit post ↗“Creed Green Irish Tweed (30ml + 1ml extra essence) Green, clean, and comforting. This scent is absolutely beautiful. I’ve almost finished the bottle already. Maturation may have shifted it slightly, but it was perfect right from the start.”
reddit post ↗“One of them was also green Irish tweed. And I can guarantee you are gonna love it. Amazing performance and scent.”
reddit ↗“I have green irish tweed from them and it smells very good, maybe better than the original because the original is a bit bitter.”
reddit ↗
Where people disagree
“GIT was pretty different, with the Shobi being a lot more harsh and there’s a lemony opening to it I didn’t really notice until I tried the OG.”
reddit ↗“try Green Irish Tweed (a lot of good reviews for Shobi's version here on reddit) and Absolute Aventus which others praise it and you didn't like it so much. GIT is a big no for me.”
reddit ↗“I bought Shobi’s Green Irish Tweed dupe on August 18: Option: Eau de Parfum Spray Bottle: 50ml Extra essence: \+5ml ( i know this is too much.. ) So, it’s had time to mature. My impressions? Pretty much the same as bef”
reddit post ↗“I ordered it 30ml+1ml and after 2 months it still smells pure detergent. Like when i open a fresh bix if detergent. There are some who dig this smell but it's unbearable to me.”
reddit ↗