Carolina Herrera Good Girl dupes — ranked by Reddit consensus
The most agreed-upon dupe for Carolina Herrera Good Girl is Lattafa Qimmah for women, named by 29 distinct people across 27 threads.
- alternatives
- 3
- in graph
- 24
- voices
- 150
Ranked alternatives
| # | Fragrance | Bucket | Evidence | Consensus | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Qimmah for women Lattafa “Lattafa qimmah (similar to good girl)”what reddit says ↓ |
| 29 voices · 27 threadssimilar vibe | 100 | |
| 02 | Bad Femme Maison Alhambra “Bad Femme Maison Alhambra is Good girl”what reddit says ↓ |
| 3 voices · 3 threadsvery close | 19 | |
| 03 | Deep Garden Zara “Deep Garden: said to be a dupe for CH Good Girl or the Legere flanker. I have the Legere one, and while it might be similar, I don’t find it is a close dupe for either, BUT I actually prefer the Zara version”what reddit says ↓ |
| 9 voices · 13 threadssimilar vibe | 11 | no offers |
What Reddit says
A sample of what people actually wrote, under the summary of it. The voice counts are the whole of the evidence behind a pairing; the quotes are a handful of the loudest, each one a link to the comment it came from.
Qimmah for womenLattafa
29 voices · 27 threads
- Reddit users generally agree that Lattafa Qimmah closely mirrors the scent profile of Good Girl, with some even preferring it to the original.
- A few reviewers note it also shares elements with Marc Jacobs Decadence before softening into the mass-appealing Good Girl aroma.
- Commenters praise Qimmah as an underrated option that lasts pretty long and comes in an attractive bottle.
“Lattafa qimmah (similar to good girl)”
reddit ↗“Qimmah by Lattafa is a great good girl dupe. I hate the GG bottle so in addition to the price difference I'm just happy to have a bottle that doesn't drive me up the wall.”
reddit ↗“Lattafa Qimmah (Carolina Herrera Good Girl)- smells the same and the bottle is gorgeous”
reddit ↗“Lattafa Qimmah is an amazing perfume. It is supposed to be a clone of CH Good girl (that I have) but better”
reddit ↗“AS TIME GOES ON ITS SPOT ON. ITS VERY WEAK AT FIST. BUT ITS WORTH IT FOR THE PRICE.”
reddit ↗
Bad FemmeMaison Alhambra
3 voices · 3 threads
Deep GardenZara
9 voices · 13 threads
- Reddit users generally describe Zara Deep Garden as sharing the Carolina Herrera Good Girl DNA, though it leans more toward a similar vibe than an exact match.
- Many reviewers characterize Deep Garden as a fresher, lighter, and more wearable daytime alternative to the original.
- Some note that it is not a direct or close clone—comparing it also to the Légère flanker—though several users actually prefer the Zara version.
“Deep garden Zara - tuberose, fresh, sweet, very feminine, floral and fruity! It is a little similar to GG Caroline Herrera”
reddit post ↗“Deep Garden: CH Good Girl”
reddit ↗“Deep Garden: said to be a dupe for CH Good Girl or the Legere flanker. I have the Legere one, and while it might be similar, I don’t find it is a close dupe for either, BUT I actually prefer the Zara version”
reddit ↗“Deep Garden- Zara. I swear this is my most complimented perfume of all time. It is a dupe, apparently, for CH good girl.”
reddit ↗“I like the Good Girl “dupe” Zara has out waaaayyyy more. More wearable for day to day. I am not a fan of all of these synthetic musk/amber/wood notes they have been using in recent years and feel many perfumes have fallen victim to the refo”
reddit ↗